CAREER DECISION TOOL

Compare two job offers

Compare estimated cash compensation, work time and commuting costs side by side. Change the inputs to see how the trade-offs affect each offer.

All figures are estimates in USD before tax. Use the same assumptions for both offers. This tool does not assign a universal “best job” score.

Offer A

Use your current job or first offer.

Offer B

Use the new offer or second option.

YOUR COMPARISON

Offer B pays more before commute costs.

Annual cash difference (B − A)+$16,000Base salary + expected bonus
Estimated commute cost difference+$1,560Annual direct commute costs
Effective hourly estimate — A$37.25/hrCash compensation less commute cost, divided by work + commute hours
Effective hourly estimate — B$36.00/hrSame simplified method for both offers
Annual work + commute time difference+390 hrsOffer B minus Offer A
Estimated annual value after commute costs+$14,440Cash compensation less direct commute costs; before tax

Breakdown by offer

MeasureOffer AOffer B
Annual cash compensation$84,000$100,000
Estimated annual commute cost$1,920$3,360
Estimated annual work hours (PTO-adjusted)1,920 hrs2,160 hrs
Estimated annual commute hours120 hrs240 hrs
Estimated effective hourly value$37.25/hr$36.00/hr

How this calculator works

Annual cash compensation is base salary plus the expected annual bonus entered above. Because bonuses may be variable, consider running a conservative scenario with a lower bonus amount.

Estimated work hours use weekly hours × (52 − paid time-off days ÷ 5). This treats five PTO days as one workweek and is a simplification; holidays, sick leave, overtime rules and part-time schedules can differ.

Commute cost and time use commute per day × on-site days per week × 52 weeks, with commute cost multiplied by estimated workdays after PTO. This estimate excludes costs you do not enter, such as parking fees or vehicle depreciation.

Effective hourly estimate is (annual cash compensation − estimated direct commute costs) ÷ (estimated work hours + annual commute hours). It is not take-home pay and does not include taxes, health insurance, retirement contributions, equity, job security or the personal value of flexibility.

Example: why salary is not the whole story

Suppose Offer B pays $16,000 more per year, but requires five extra work hours each week and an additional half-hour of commuting each on-site day. The higher salary may still be worthwhile, but the extra time changes the practical value of the offer. Comparing the same inputs for both jobs makes that trade-off visible.

Before you decide

  • Confirm which bonus amounts are guaranteed and which are performance-based.
  • Ask about typical—not just contracted—weekly hours and busy periods.
  • Include retirement matching, insurance, equity and other benefits separately.
  • Consider manager quality, learning, stability, flexibility and future opportunities.
  • Run best-case and conservative scenarios instead of trusting a single estimate.

Frequently asked questions

Does this calculate take-home pay?

No. All compensation figures are gross estimates before tax. Tax outcomes depend on location and personal circumstances.

Does paid time off reduce my salary?

No. PTO is used only to estimate hours worked. Annual salary remains unchanged in this calculation.

Should I include a target bonus?

You can include it, but treat uncertain bonuses cautiously. Run a second comparison with the bonus set to zero or to a conservative expected amount.

Does a higher effective hourly estimate mean I should take that job?

Not automatically. The estimate covers only the money and time inputs on this page. Career development, benefits, workplace conditions and personal preferences can change the decision.